Merry fucking Christmas!
It's still technically too early to say for certain, but I would be shocked if my insurance company didn't write off my car. The real tragedy is that I only had one year of payments left on the car. Even if I just try to find a nice "certified used" car, I'm now looking at two years of payments, minimum, and we were counting on having that money feed up at the end of next year.
Anyway, I'm probably being far too pessimistic about the situation, but right now I'm angry, depressed and frankly just feeling like our financial situation -- which not too long ago felt like was clearing up -- has just completely bottomed out again.
I certainly hope that getting some decent sleep tonight will help.
Edit to Add (Dec. 15, 7:05 AM): Just to clarify, my car was not the one stolen. It was parked in a spot no more than a couple dozen feet away from where the (presumably) stolen vehicle was and was hit when that car peeled off. There was a witness, and he called the police, who relayed those details to me.